The demise of Bear Stearns

Bear Stearns has been absorbed by JP Morgan for just $2 per share – reportedly valuing the company at $236 million. It has been a dramatic collapse of a Wall Street Firm that was the darling of employees and stock markets. The employees seem to own nearly 30% of the company (though a significant chunk is likely to be owned by the top few executives) and it has been a terrible loss of personal wealth for them.

I feel sorry for Bear Stearns employees and investors. But I think such incidents tend to make the market healthier by weeding out excesses.

It is apt to be a little philosophical at times like these. Incidents like these reinforce our belief in the laws of Systems Thinking and Behavioral Economics

a) In my post of 30th March 2007, I had discussed how the ballooning asset bubble was threatening to push the financial markets off a cliff and the events that are unfolding now were not so hard to predict even a year earlier.
b) Students of Game Theory know about “Prisoner’s Dilemma”. To cut a long story short, it says that every individual acts in his own interest, thereby causing systemic failures. This failure ends up harming the individuals’ interest which they thought they could protect by acting in a “selfish” manner. Run on banks follows the same principle. When everyone is in a hurry to withdraw their assets from a bank (to protect their own savings, and in hurry to withdraw the asset before the neighbor next door does so), the bank collapses. It does not require erosion in the value of assets of the bank to trigger a crisis like this – it requires just erosion in confidence in the bank.
c) “The law of unintended consequences” is playing catch up: The last few moves of the Fed have had quite a few undesirable effects. Excessive rate cuts by the US Fed have always created asset bubbles – Nasdaq, Subprime, and now a short lived bubble in emerging market equities. Despite the rate cuts, the mortgage crisis is only gathering pace and the economy does not seem to stop sinking into a recession.

The US Fed is blamed by many for taking no action to prvent the crisis. It is interesting to read the comments of Alan Greenspan, the former Fed Chairman, as gathered by Paul Krugman, a columnist with the New York Times

What Greenspan said: “The current financial crisis in the US is likely to be judged in retrospect as the most wrenching since the end of the second world war. It will end eventually when home prices stabilise and with them the value of equity in homes supporting troubled mortgage securities.
Home price stabilisation will restore much-needed clarity to the marketplace because losses will be realised rather than prospective. The major source of contagion will be removed. Financial institutions will then recapitalise or go out of business. Trust in the solvency of remaining counterparties will be gradually restored and issuance of loans and securities will slowly return to normal.”

What Keynes said: In the long run we are all dead. Economists set themselves too easy, too useless a task if in tempestuous seasons they can only tell us that when the storm is long past the ocean is flat again.

Debunk the Decoupling Theory Atleast Now

My comments on January 20th (read post on this link) have all come true !!!

Just a day after I posted the comment, the Indian stock market fell 10% on an intraday basis. The next day it fell another 14% on an intraday basis. Though stock markets recovered a bit, they have been on a down-trend ever since.

It takes a brave man to voice opinion against the wisdom of the crowds and the events over the last few weeks make me feel vindicated.

What were those predictions and how have they markets shaped up against these predictions ?

a) During a downturn, money flows into the home market
There have been huge outflows from emerging markets. Indian and Chinese stock markets have been the worst performers this year.

b) If there is a recession in the US, no country can fully decouple itself and maintain its growth rate

There are signs of sluggishness in the Indian economy. Reports indicate that India’s Industrial Production grew by only 5.3% in January. Bank of China estimates Chinese GDP growth to slow down. Decoupling theory has now given way to Recoupling theory !!!

c) Reckless rate cuts will only stoke inflation rather providing a real impetus to growth (China is currently witnessing inflation of over 6% and the authorities have committed themselves to fight it through a tight monetary policy). Despite the heavy fall in short term interest rates in the US, the long term interest rates have refused to budge, indicating bullishness on inflation trends.

Just look at Gold and Oil. Gold has reached $1000 and oil has crossed $110 – close to a 100% gain in the last 12 months.

How do you position yourself ?

a) Act like a hedge fund; have a long-and short strategy. Immediately switch out of stocks that are dependent on discretionary consumer spending in the US. You can buy into emerging market equities on dips, but buy into those stocks which have lower export component and are fairly valued. Don’t buy stocks whose valuations are can be justified only by a great growth story.
The Indian and Chinese markets have fallen 25% from the peak and people who bought into “growth stocks” have burnt their fingers very badly.

b) If you play commodities, play agri-commodities – the switch from food to fuel is unlikely reverse in a hurry and will help maintain an upward bias on prices.
Soybean, Corn, and Wheat futures have gained around 25 percent from the time I posted the message two months back.

c) If you are currency trader, short the dollar and the pound and go long on the Chinese Yuan. The Chinese government is not answerable to its people and will not mind paying the cost of holding a huge forex reserve (the reserve is already worth about $1.6 trillion – over 50% of its GDP). The government is in NO mood to let the currency seek its natural level and China's trade surplus is not going to disappear in a hurry
Dollar is at an all time low versus a basket of currencies and the Yuan has gained further ground against the dollar. A short position on the dollar and long position on the yuan would have given handsome rewards.